Tag: animal rights

  • Elephant Habeas Case: Steven Wise Loses; Elephants Unavailable For Comment

    Elephant Habeas Case: Steven Wise Loses; Elephants Unavailable For Comment

    The case of the day is Nonhuman Rights Project, Inc. ex rel. Beulah et al. v. R.W. Commerford & Sons, Inc. (Conn. Super. Ct. 2017). I wrote a polemic about the case back in November 2017. The case was a petition for habeas corpus brought by Steven Wise’s group, the Nonhuman Rights Project, on behalf……

  • Attention PETA!

    Attention PETA!

    I wrote back in 2015 about the Monkey Selfie case. As the name suggests, a monkey took a selfie using a camera that a nature photographer set up in the monkey’s forest. PETA then brought a lawsuit against the photographer, alleging, supposedly on behalf of the monkey, that the monkey owned the copyright to the……

  • Elephant Habeas Case: Steven Wise is a Well-Intentioned Menace

    Elephant Habeas Case: Steven Wise is a Well-Intentioned Menace

    At the bitter end of the Monkey Selfie case, I pointed out that the “animals are people” genre of animal rights litigation isn’t just a feel-good resume builder for bright 2Ls in the animal rights clinic. It has real victims. In the Monkey Selfie case, the victim was David Slater, the photographer, who went broke……

  • Monkey Selfie Case Settles

    Monkey Selfie Case Settles

    The Monkey Selfie case has come to a depressing and cynical end. The case had to do with a photograph of an Indonesian monkey. David Slater, a professional photographer, set up a camera on a tripod in the monkey’s habitat and left the camera’s remote trigger near the camera. One monkey, Naruto, picked up the……

  • Comments on the “Monkey Selfie” Case

    Comments on the “Monkey Selfie” Case

    When I was a law clerk, a lawyer filed a civil rights action in my judge’s court (the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio) against an Ohio municipality, several police officers, and Lieutenant Bars. When I read the complaint, I was momentarily confused. Who was Lieutenant Bars? Why, the police dog, of……